|
The heads of 30 UK Cancer charities have written to Work and Pensions Secretary to protest at provisions in the Welfare Reform Bill which they say will leave thousands of cancer patients without vital financial assistance when they need it most.
They argue that proposals to limit ESA to 12 months for those who are required to carry out work-focussed activities would see this vital finanical assistance removed for many cancer sufferers receiving treatments, before they have fully recovered.
The full text of their letter follows:-
Dear secretary of state,
In advance of the second reading of the welfare reform bill, we are writing to ask you to consider the impact your
proposed reform of the welfare system will have on people living with cancer in the UK.
We
agree that the welfare system needs reform and welcome proposals to
simplify a system that is currently confusing and bureaucratic. We also
welcome your commitment to make the transition from benefits to work
easier and more rewarding for many people.
However, we are
extremely concerned that changes to disability benefits will mean that a
significant number of people with cancer will be left without vital
financial support at a time when they need it the most. We would like to
work with you to make sure this government's welfare reforms do not
have the very undesirable consequence of pushing some people with cancer
into poverty.
Reform of Disability Living Allowance (DLA)
First,
we are very concerned by the proposal that people with cancer will have
to wait six months before they can claim the new Personal Independence
Payment (PIP), which will replace DLA. We know that even the existing
three-month wait for DLA is extremely problematic for people with
cancer.
Cancer treatment often starts very quickly following
diagnosis and the needs associated with cancer can escalate rapidly. In
the first six months following diagnosis, people with cancer face
dramatically increased outgoings to cover expenses such as travel and
parking for hospital appointments and extra fuel costs.
Without
support for these costs as soon as the need arises, people with cancer
will face increased levels of hardship and some will get further into
debt. We hope you will ensure that those whose condition is likely to be
long-term, and who face extra costs immediately, will be able to
receive the PIP when they need it.
Changes to Employment and Support Allowance (ESA)
Second,
we believe the bill is an opportunity to address the existing inequity
faced by cancer patients where a patient's choice of preferred method of
treatment can affect how their eligibility for ESA is determined.
Currently,
only people who are receiving non-oral chemotherapy are automatically
exempt from having to undergo the medical assessment and placed in the
support group – where they are not forced to take part in work-related
activities such as practice job interviews as a condition of receiving
the benefit. This is in recognition of the very debilitating effects of
this treatment.
However, those people receiving oral chemotherapy
or radiotherapy treatment, which is in many instances just as physically
and psychologically debilitating, must undergo the medical assessment
and may be required to participate in work-related activities as a
condition of receiving their benefit.
Since the introduction of
ESA, medical advances mean that oral chemotherapies are used
increasingly to treat more aggressive forms of cancer. Sometimes cancer
patients can choose to take the same chemotherapy drug either orally or
non-orally. Currently, their choice will affect the way they are treated
in the benefit system.
Finally, proposals that ESA claimants who
are expected to carry out work-focused activities will only receive the
benefit for one year, without being means-tested, will hit cancer
patients particularly hard.
The majority of people with cancer who
are out of work want to return to work. It can represent a milestone in
their recovery and a return to normality, in addition to the obvious
financial benefits. We believe that this proposal, rather than creating
an incentive to work, will lead to many cancer patients losing their ESA
simply because they have not recovered quickly enough.
For many
cancer patients it takes longer than a year to return to work. This is
evident from your department's own statistics, which show that 75% of
cancer patients who could be affected by this policy still need ESA
after one year. This is due to the length of time people with cancer
experience the debilitating effects of cancer or its treatment and the
multiple barriers they face in getting back to work.
These can
include discrimination or employers unwilling to make reasonable
adjustments, such as offering flexible working hours or a phased return.
People
with cancer, and the parents of children with cancer, are very worried
about how the welfare reform bill will affect them. Living with cancer
is expensive and many people rely on benefits to make ends meet. We hope
you will ensure that your reform of the welfare system works for people
with cancer, so that cancer patients receive the support they need when
they need it the most.
Naturally, we would welcome the
opportunity to discuss these issues with you personally and hope we can
work together to make the necessary adjustments to the bill as it goes
through parliament to reflect our serious concerns.
Yours sincerely,
Ciarán Devane, chief executive, Macmillan Cancer Support
Henny Braund, chief executive, Anthony Nolan
Mark Flannagan, chief executive, Beating Bowel Cancer
Jenny Baker OBE, chief executive, Brain Tumour UK
Chris Askew, chief executive, Breakthrough Breast Cancer
Samia al Qadhi, chief executive, Breast Cancer Care
Helen Bulbeck, director, brainstrust - the Meg Jones brain cancer charity
Pamela Goldberg, chief executive, Breast Cancer Campaign
Deborah Alsina, chief executive, Bowel Cancer UK
Harpal Kumar, chief executive, Cancer Research UK
Elaine Kerr, chief executive, Chai Cancer Care
Lorraine Clifton, chief executive, CLIC Sargent
Kristin Hallenga, chief executive, CoppaFeel
Nick Turkentine, chief executive, James Whale Fund
Robert Music, director, Jo's Cervical Cancer Trust
Karen Friett, chief executive, Lymphoedema Support Network
Sally Penrose, chief executive, Lymphoma Association
Dr Teresa Tate, medical adviser, Marie Curie Cancer Care
Ella Pybus, chief executive, Meningioma UK
Dr Vinod K Joshi, founder and chief executive. Mouth Cancer Foundation
Eric Low, chief executive, Myeloma UK
John Solly, chief executive, Myrovlytis Trust
Alexandra Ford, chief executive, Pancreatic Cancer UK
John Neate, chief executive, The Prostate Cancer Charity
Andrew Wilson, chief executive, Rarer Cancers Foundation
Rosemary Gillespie, chief executive, The Roy Castle Lung Cancer Foundation
Paul Carbury, chief executive, Samantha Dickson Brain Tumour Trust
Lindsey Bennister, chief executive, Sarcoma UK
Anwen Jones, chief executive, Target Ovarian Cancer
Simon Davies, chief executive, Teenage Cancer Trust
|